Skip to main content

Hi, Keanu! Here's the real story of the 47 rōnin.

Chūshingura (忠臣蔵). Is there anyone in Japan – nay, the world! – who doesn't know this story? It's been told in novels, kabuki, bunraku, films and TV shows, and now Keanu Reeves has tackled it in his movie 47 Rōnin.

When I first heard about the film, I was thrilled, but now that I've seen the trailer … uh-oh. It's a fantasy-adventure-martial arts mishmash that can't decide whether it's Star Wars, The Matrix or The Last Samurai; but perhaps the full-length feature is better than the trailer.

Keanu Reeves in 47 Rōnin

The real leader of the 47 rōnin, Ōishi Yoshio,
at Sengaku-ji

Everybody will be talking about it, though, so let's look at the real story of the 47 rōninIt's based on historical facts. As briefly as possible this is what happened in 1701:

A country baron called Asano Naganori was appointed by the shōgun to receive the emperor's ambassadors. Since Asano was unfamiliar with court etiquette, a higher-ranking nobleman called Kira Yoshinaka was instructed to act as his mentor. Then disaster struck: Asano tried to assassinate Kira. He only wounded the older man, but it was such a serious violation of etiquette that the shōgun ordered Asano to commit a ritual suicide known as seppuku. His lands were confiscated and his retainers were released as rōnin, or masterless samurai without a job.

They plotted revenge, and by using a combination of patience, cunning and self-sacrifice they finally – two years after their lord's death! – broke into Kira's mansion at night and killed him. After they were arrested, they followed their master's example by committing seppuku.

These real events turned into the stuff of legend almost immediately: only three years later Chikamatsu immortalized it in a bunraku play. Various versions of the story followed, but the most famous is Kana dehon chūshingura (仮名手本忠臣蔵) written in 1748 by three authors including Takeda Izumo. It's in every child's school textbooks, it's performed every New Year, it's been filmed countless times.

Why did Asano try to kill Kira? It's not clear, but many theories have been proposed:

  • Kira flirted with Asano's young wife.
  • Kira was responsible for instructing the younger Asano in the rules of court etiquette, and deliberately taught him the wrong rules in order to humiliate him.
  • Kira was Asano's mentor, and as such, Asano had to thank Kira with symbolic gifts. Asano's gifts weren't good enough, Kira started treating him with contempt, Asano retaliated with an attempted murder.

Actually, the motive is irrelevant. What makes this story so enormously popular in Japan is the triumph of giri (義理 or social obligations) over ninjō (人情 or human feelings). That's probably the theme of 90% of Japanese stories, but the tale of the 47 rōnin illustrates it particularly well.

It also explains why the leader of the rōnin, Ōishi Yoshio (大石 良雄), is the real hero of the story.

Weird movie posters. No, I don't know why she's upside down.

Ian Buruma says in his book A Japanese Mirror – Heroes and Villains of Japanese Culture:

An important element in their heroism is the directness, the unthinkingness of their actions. There is a certain type of hero who appeals greatly to the popular imagination. He is the opposite of the stereotyped image people generally have of the average Japanese – which is perhaps partly why he is a hero. One is often told, usually by Japanese themselves, that losing one's temper is tantamount to losing face. This may be so, but this type of hero is nothing if not quick-tempered. [Asano] is of course the prime example: his first reaction is to use his sword …

This emphasis on blind, emotional action points to one of the most significant paradoxes underlying Japanese culture: namely that a highly conformist people obsessed with etiquette and social propriety should ideally be swayed by their innermost emotions …

It does put giri and other social obligations in an interesting light: while giri is ostensibly part of a social system to keep the wilder emotions in check, it can just as easily be employed as an excuse to give them free reign. After all, any amount of fanaticism can he excused in the name of giri, particularly as rationality is not only not a necessity, but not even really desirable.

It is, however, private inclination restrained to bursting point that provides the real tension in Japanese drama. The consummate Japanese hero, admired even more than honest hot-heads, never breaks out wildly immediately. Heroes … are a little like hissing and puffing pressure cookers, and it is at the final breaking point that the audience applauds. It is the period of enduring the unendurable that makes the final act of revenge so cathartic. Gaman, meaning perseverance, endurance or sufferance, is as much a virtue as makoto [sincerity, truth, faith].

Asano and his 47 retainers were buried at a Sōtō Zen temple in Shinagawa called Sengaku-ji (泉岳寺).

The outer gate of Sengaku-ji

The inner gate of Sengaku-ji


It's a fairly low-key temple, but it was quite busy on the day that I went there – though most of the visitors were office workers having lunch and a group of seniors painting the temple's famous main gate. The latter is registered as a Tangible Cultural Property in Minato-ku.

It took me a few minutes and a lot of frowning, muttering and grumbling to figure out where the graves are: towards your left if you face the main temple, tucked away in a corner of the graveyard. You'll find all 47 graves there, with incense and candles burning at most of them, and friendly ojiisan guarding the gate (and following you to check that you know the story).

The path leading towards the graves of the 47 rōnin

A map indicates where each warrior is buried.

47 graves

It is a somewhat unsettling experience to stand there, surrounded by the graves of men who were willing to die for their lord. I caught myself wondering, "What would I be willing to die for?" That question remains unanswered. (I would fight to protect my books and my chocolate supply, but you're going to die, not me!)

I end with Asano's death poem:


kaze sasou / hana yori mo nao / ware wa mata / haru no nagori wo / ika ni toyasen

More than the cherry blossoms,
Inviting a wind to blow them away,
I am wondering what to do
With the remaining springtime.

Looking towards the inner gate from the main temple.
Isn't that a gorgeous pine tree?

Looking towards the main temple from the inner gate

Ru loves roofs.

View Larger Map

Popular posts from this blog

Day Zero: when Cape Town's taps are turned off

Sleet in Tokyo, 0 degrees Celsius, possibly colder in my north-facing apartment. Opened tap and warmed hands under running water until I remembered where I'm from. Cape Town. A city without water. They will run out of water ... soon, April, perhaps sooner, and there I was, indolently watching water spiraling down the drain.

South Africa: rich in natural resources, poor in water. Japan: zero natural resources, So Much Water.

I took these two photos of the Theewaterskloof Dam in January 2017, when there was still some water left. Now there's virtually nothing.

Capetonians have been asked to limit their water consumption to 50 liters a day. Here's how it breaks down:

Only a minority is currently following these guidelines. The rest: ignorant or selfish or stupid or all three.

"I can get my head around drinking water: you transport it by truck," I told my family. "I understand that you can do a hospital bath with Wet Wipes instead of a bath-bath. I accept that la…

What do you do with your toilet if there's no water?

This is a follow-up to my previous post about apocalyptic waterless Cape Town. "Toilets! What do?" I asked my friends. Ah, you apply a little rhyme that's now doing the rounds. You apply it everywhere, even in public toilets.

if it's yellow
let it mellow
if it's brown
flush it down

I'm continuing my own water-saving experiment, partly because I'm curious, partly out of sympathy with my beloved Cape Town. It's all very un-serious in my case, of course: yesterday, for example, I put a teabag in hot water and then -- as I do so frequently -- forgot about it. Usually I would've thrown it out. Yesterday I drank tepid tea. Every drop counts.

En as dit nie anders kan nie, is daar altyd Japannese whisky (al die pad saamgepiekel SA toe) en Klippies en plaaslike wyn.

Higanbana, a flower of loss and longing

I love this flower. I love all flowers, but this one, ah, this one comes packaged with the most wonderful stories. Its scientific name is Lycoris radiata; in English it's red spider lily; in Japanese it has several names including higanbana (ヒガンバナ), in other words, autumn equinox flower.

It's also referred to as manjusaka (曼珠沙華), based on an old Chinese legend about two elves: Manju guarded the flowers and Saka the leaves, but they could never meet, because the plant never bears flowers and leaves at the same time. They were curious about each other, so they defied the gods' instructions and arranged a meeting. I assume it was not via Twitter. The gods promptly punished them, as gods are wont to do, and separated them for all eternity.
To this day, the red lily is associated with loss, longing, abandonment and lost memories in hanakotoba(花言葉), the language of flowers. It's believed that if you meet a person you'll never see again, these flowers will grow along your…

Water crisis? But ... you've got a big lake!

I should be used to ignorance about South Africa -- or South Shithole, if you prefer -- but my students never fail to shock me into silence.

Office worker in her late 30s. Where are you from? Cape Town. Where is that? Cape Town in South Africa. South America? No, look at this map: this is South Africa and this is Cape Town. How about Cape Town? The latter is studentspeak for "I don't know anything about Cape Town; could you please tell me more; do you like it; if yes, what are you doing in Japan?"

I explain a bit. "Is it very hot?" I explain a bit more, and mention the current water crisis, which means my beloved city will run out of water in April.

The student looks at the map. "But," she says and points, genuinely puzzled, "you have a very big lake!"

South Africa is not a safety country (hallelujah)

I did. Smile. Nonstop. Al die pad dwarsdeur end-uit.

The ultimate guide to Kanda Myojin

I'm floundering. I don't know how to start a post about Kanda Myōjin (神田明神), because how do you choose a highlight from this collection below?
The decapitated head of a rebellious samurai who's still haunting Ōtemachi is buried in the vicinity, and his deified spirit is enshrined here.It's been called the world's geekiest shrine thanks to its proximity to otaku heaven Akihabara. The shrine has a Facebook, Twitter and LINE account.You can see some extremely generously endowed young ladies on the shrine's ema.It has a horse. A real horse. A tiny living breathing pony.Birds protect it against fire.
See my problem? Where do I start the ultimate guide to the ultimate shrine?

Why Kanda Myōjin?
Let's be boring and kick off with my own connection with Kanda Myōjin, which is very simple: I've always lived within walking distance of the shrine. My first four years in Tokyo were spent in Kanda, blissfully close to the book district Jinbōchō, and I frequently passed …

The Princess Who Loved Insects (updated)

My blog gets so many search keyword hits about this particular topic that I've decided to update an old post about the Japenese story The Princess Who Loved Insects(虫めづる姫君Mushi Mezuru Himegimi).

It's contained in Tales of the Riverside Middle Counselor (堤中納言物語Tsutsumi Chūnagon Monogatari), a collection of short stories written in the late Heian period. It focuses on the adventures of a young girl who refuses to make herself beautiful and play the courtship game. She doesn't blacken her teeth and pluck her eyebrows (as refined ladies did in those days); instead, she spends her time outdoors, playing with bugs and caterpillars.

I refer to her as Ms Mushi (Ms Insect).  A girl this tough is definitely not a prim prissy Miss, she's a ballsy Ms. She's my favourite Japanese heroine. She's strong, she's rebellious, she refuses to pretend, she ignores society's stupid rules that fetter women. You go, girl! Long live caterpillar eyebrows!

Donald Keene mentions in hi…

Ek mis die niks

As jy van ver af aankom, sê maar van Skilpadtepel se kant af, dan sien jy eers niks, en na ’n rukkie nóg niks, en dan die kerk se kliptoring, en naderhand ook die troppie huise daar rondom. Hulle staan soos ’n klein skaretjie om ’n ongelukstoneel – almal wil bý wees maar niemand wil dit té naby waag nie. -- Oom Kootjie Emmer, André P. Brink Dis goed om my eie taal te lees. Daardie paragraaf herinner my so intens aan Kamieskroon, die Namakwalandse dorpie waar my ouma gewoon het; en die talle klein dorpies op die platteland in Suid-Afrika.

A year that's already gone to the dogs

2018 is the year of the dog. I photographed these ema at Hie Jinja, which always has big variety of designs. Indigenous species such as the shiba inu and the Akita inu feature prominently.

Hiking along the Mitake Valley in Okutama

I'm lying. Exaggerating. It's not hiking; it's walking.

As a matter of fact, the Mitake Valley Riverside Trail has given me a new definition of walking vs hiking: if you encounter vending machines along the way, it's walking, not hiking.
I've done several hikes in Okutama, but I'm going to start with this walk because anybody can do it. It's exceptionally beautiful, truly pleasant and very easy. You don't need to be an experienced hiker, you don't need hiking boots, you don't need energy drinks – or Scotch – to keep going.

It starts at Ikusabata Station on the Ōme Line, follows the Tama River and ends about 5 km upstream. It took me about two hours of slow walking, many photos, frequent diversions and arbitrary stops to enjoy the autumn colours.
Let's do this section by section. Warning: this post is photo-heavy!
Ikusabata to Sawai

It takes 90 minutes from Tokyo Station. Take the Chūō Line to Ōme, transfer to the Ōme Line and get off at Ikusab…